Meshugana Deli Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Meshugana Deli, nestled in sunny Sarasota, Florida! This local gem is renowned for its piled-high sandwiches, offering a whopping 10 oz of hand-sliced meats that speak to authenticity and flavor. The Tanya's Sandwich, featuring grilled pastrami nestled in house-baked seeded rye, is a must-try alongside your choice of delectable sides like Grandma's Chicken Matzoh Ball Soup and seasonal fruit salad.
Diving into dessert, indulge in classics such as rich cheesecake slices and the delightful Boston Whoopie Pie. What sets Meshugana Deli apart is its welcoming, New York-inspired atmosphere and friendly service that makes every visit special. Customers rave about the robust flavors and generous portions, creating an experience that resonates with both nostalgia and sheer culinary pleasure. Don’t miss out on a taste of tradition - your taste buds will thank you!
Sandwiches
Tanya's Sandwich
A delicious Grilled Pastrami Sandwich with lettuce, tomato, Cheddar cheese and a Horseradish Russian Dressing on our HOUSE BAKED SEEDED RYE. Comes with pickle and one side choice.
Meshugana Sampler
PILED-HIGH Sandwiches
Our HAND SLICED pile high sandwiches come with 10 oz of meat! Just meat and bread and you add the rest!! Can you say Crazy Delicious! Comes with a pickle and a side choice.
Salad Sandwiches
Choice of our Homemade Tuna Salad, Chicken Salad, Egg Salad or Chopped Liver. Whitefish salad is also available! Comes with pickle and a side salad.
Reuben Sandwiches
Traditional Ruben comes grilled with Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese and Russian dressing. BUT, this time...you choose the meat! Comes with a pickle and a side choice. Add some dessert to 'sweeten' your meal!
Rachel Sandwiches
Substitute Cole Slaw for your Sauerkraut on a Ruben and what do you have? A Rachel!! Grilled sandwich comes with Coleslaw, Swiss cheese and Russian Dressing. You choose the MEAT! Comes with a pickle and a side choice.
Daily Special
Misc Item
New Jersey Sloppy Joe
Choice Of 2 Meats,Coleslaw, Russian Dressing
Half Sandwich And Cup Soup Combo
Can't finish a whole sandwich? 1/2 sandwich of your choice with a cup of Homemade Matzoh Ball Soup.
Hebrew National Hotdog
Comes with a pickle and a side choice.
Seasonal Fruit Salad
1lb Vibrant Seasonal Fruit Salad to beat the summer heat!
Garden Salad
A delicious mix of baby greens with tomato, cucumbers and carrots. Choice of Dressing: Russian, Balsamic Vinaigrette or Blue Cheese. Add a scoop of Egg Salad, Chicken Salad, or Tuna Salad or meat for an additional charge.
Side Salad (LG)
Half Seedless Rye Loaf
Half Seeded Rye Loaf
Full Seedless Rye Loaf
Matzo Ball (1)
Full Seeded Rye Loaf
Chicken Matzo Ball Soup - CUP
Grandma's Matzoh Ball soup made with real Whole Chicken, Parsnips, Carrots, Celery, Onions, Slowly Braised for three-four hours.
2 Slices Of Bread
Chicken Matzoh Ball Soup - QUART
Grandma's Matzoh Ball soup made with real Whole Chicken, Parsnips, Carrots, Celery, Onions, Slowly Braised for three-four hours.
Full Pan Noodle Kugel (16PCS)
1/2 Pan Noodle Kugel (8PCS)
Noodle Kugel
Sweet Noodle Pudding with Pineapple, creamy cottage cheese mixed in a light custard.
Cheese Blintzes (4)
Buy 1 Dozen Knishes Get (2) Free
Buy 1/2 Dozen Knishes Get (1) Free
Knishes
Puffed Pastry filled with fluffy mashed potato with caramelized onion. Or try our four hour Braised Brisket Knish...YUM!
Potato Latkes (3)
Served with Applesauce and Sour Cream.
Sides
Desserts
Small Chocolate Chip Cookie
A delicious buttery loaded with chocolate chocolate chip cookie!!
Large Chocolate Chip Cookie
Boston Whoopie Pie
Chocolate Cake Cookie with a Sweet Marshmallow filling.
Hamantash
Assorted Mini Box (ALL MINI ITEMS INCLUDED)
Mini Cookies
Mini Macaroons
Mini Black & White Cookie
Strawberry Shortcake
Mini Pies
Carrot Cake
Sufganiyah
Honey Apple Cake
Rice Pudding 1#
Babka Bun
Truffles
Appleberry Filo Tart
Bread Pudding
Rugelach 1/2#
Palmier
Babka
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Mini Linzer Tart
Coconut Bar
Russian Tea Cake
Cheesecake Slice
Large Coconut Macaroon
Rugelach
Large Black And White Cookie
Cup
Shirt
Merch
Sandwich Packages
Delivery Charge
The Mazel Tov Dairy Packages
The Mazel Tov Dairy Package
The Oy-Vey Sandwich Large (12-15)
The Oy-Vey Sandwich Platter -Medium
The Oy-Vey Sandwich Package
Brewed Beverage
NY Chocolate Egg Cream
Coffee
Tropicana Juice
Bottled Tea
Coke
Bottled Water
Dr. Brown
Beverage
Bagels
Jalapeo Cheddar Bagel
Blueberry Bagel
Bakers Dozen Bagel Special w/ Two 1/2 lb Cream Cheeses
Enjoy a Bakers Dozen of our Homemade NY Bagels (it's not the water!) and two 1/2 lb tubs of the cream cheese of your choosing (all made in house!)
Honey Walnut Cream Cheese
Rye Bagel
Bialy - Onion
Breakfast Sandwich
Better than Bacon Breakfast Sandwiches!! Start with Egg and Cheese on a Bagel and add any of our delicious meats. Choice of cheeses and bagel flavor...yum!!
Test
Salt
Whitefish Spread
Veggie Cream Cheese
Scallion Cream Cheese
Plain Cream Cheese
Nova lox Spread
Pickled Herring 1/4 Lb
Creamed Herring 1/4 Lb
Nova Works "THE WORKS"
Delicious Nova Salmon on a bagel of your choosing topped with plain cream cheese, capers, onions, tomatoes, and cucumbers.